Popular
What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?
Recognizing Gaslighting
What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?
Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring
What are VPNs, and why are they in the news always?
Few terms coming up in focus to understand the troubled global economy
U.S. Fed interest rate hike and its impact on India
Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past and the present 
Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the news always?
The world faces a growing stagflationary storm
Politics Science News
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Economics Environment Global Reports/Agreements In pictures Intl. Organisations Personalities Politics Science & Tech Theory / Facts World World History All
      Economics

      Few terms coming up in focus to understand…

      29th July 2022

      Economics

      Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the…

      23rd May 2022

      Economics

      The world faces a growing stagflationary storm

      5th May 2022

      Economics

      What is and Why De-Dollarisation?

      22nd April 2022

      Economics

      Explained – The U.S. Federal Reserve to increase…

      8th February 2022

      Economics

      All you need to know about the Natural…

      24th January 2022

      Economics

      The Truth about “Tax the Rich”

      27th December 2021

      Economics

      Venezuela Crisis

      2nd October 2021

      Environment

      World Air Quality Report 

      28th March 2022

      Environment

      Why should we be worried about topsoil erosion?

      21st March 2022

      Environment

      Effects of Climate Change

      30th July 2021

      Environment

      Implications of a Tragic Love Story – Coral…

      4th June 2021

      Global Reports/Agreements

      IPCC Report 2022

      8th March 2022

      Global Reports/Agreements

      The Climate Change Negotiations – UNFCCC and Paris…

      3rd August 2021

      Global Reports/Agreements

      Understanding World Happiness Report

      15th April 2021

      In pictures

      World War 2 Summary (1939 to 1945)

      9th July 2020

      In pictures

      World War I – 1914-1918

      30th June 2020

      Intl. Organisations

      What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

      5th January 2023

      Intl. Organisations

      International Energy Agency (IEA)

      15th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)

      12th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC)

      10th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      What is the G20 Summit?

      31st October 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      What is QUAD? | Quadrilateral Security Dialogue

      10th October 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      SCO – What is Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

      28th September 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      G7 GROUP

      24th September 2021

      Personalities

      Gramsci Prison Notebooks

      18th November 2021

      Personalities

      John Stuart Mill: Theories

      10th September 2021

      Personalities

      Understanding Rousseau, Jean-Jacques

      4th July 2021

      Personalities

      John Locke – Father of Liberalism

      14th June 2021

      Personalities

      Hobbes Leviathan – Political Philosophy of Hobbes

      22nd May 2021

      Personalities

      Chanakya Strategies in administration

      30th March 2021

      Personalities

      Who was Machiavelli? – The Prince Summary and…

      3rd March 2021

      Personalities

      Aristotle – A Greek Philosopher

      25th January 2021

      Politics

      What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

      21st October 2022

      Politics

      Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

      18th August 2022

      Politics

      Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past…

      27th May 2022

      Politics

      Sudan’s Nightmare: The Conflict Explained

      9th January 2022

      Politics

      What’s happening between Ukraine and Russia?

      12th December 2021

      Politics

      China Taiwan Conflict

      7th October 2021

      Politics

      Taliban taking over Afghanistan

      18th August 2021

      Politics

      Armenian Genocide – What Happened?

      24th April 2021

      Science & Tech

      What are VPNs, and why are they in…

      29th July 2022

      Science & Tech

      Does Splinternet mean the end of the Internet?

      6th April 2022

      Science & Tech

      What you must know about the world’s first…

      2nd January 2022

      Science & Tech

      Omicron: Everything you need to know about COVID-19…

      5th December 2021

      Science & Tech

      Dopamine Happy Hormone

      14th August 2021

      Science & Tech

      How to avoid trans fat?

      7th August 2021

      Science & Tech

      Mental Health during the COVID19 pandemic 

      27th June 2021

      Science & Tech

      CRISPR Nobel Prize 2020 – What is it…

      27th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      What is Fascism?

      21st July 2021

      Theory / Facts

      Banality of Evil

      14th July 2021

      Theory / Facts

      Evolution of Western Political Thought

      19th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      What is Game Theory in Politics?

      10th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      Demarcation of Powers and Responsibilities

      13th September 2019

      Theory / Facts

      Realist vs Idealist

      2nd September 2019

      World

      The Truth about Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster

      28th February 2022

      World

      Djokovic Visa Controversy – More Than What Meets…

      17th January 2022

      World

      Happiest Countries in the World – Top 10

      5th April 2021

      World

      5 Women making history in 2021 – Women…

      21st March 2021

      World

      Five demonstrations that changed history

      5th February 2021

      World

      Myanmar Story

      2nd February 2021

      World

      India and Global Nuclear Order

      31st January 2021

      World

      Nuclear Proliferation

      30th January 2021

      World History

      Israel Palestine Conflict

      11th May 2021

      World History

      What is Cold War? – Cold War Summary

      11th February 2021

      World History

      Russian Revolution

      10th January 2021

      World History

      The Soviet Union Collapse and End of Cold…

      30th December 2020

      World History

      French Revolution – What happened?

      3rd December 2020

      World History

      American Revolution Summary

      28th November 2020

      World History

      South Korea vs North Korea

      12th September 2020

      World History

      World War 2 Summary (1939 to 1945)

      9th July 2020

      Topics

      What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

      5th January 2023

      Topics

      What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

      21st October 2022

      Topics

      Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

      18th August 2022

      Topics

      What are VPNs, and why are they in…

      29th July 2022

      Topics

      Few terms coming up in focus to understand…

      29th July 2022

      Topics

      Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past…

      27th May 2022

      Topics

      Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the…

      23rd May 2022

      Topics

      The world faces a growing stagflationary storm

      5th May 2022

  • NewsFeed
  • Miscellaneous
  • Videos
  • Archives
India

AFSPA – The Controversial Law

by Admin 15th September 2019
15th September 2019
AFSPA
345

AFSPA – Armed Forces (Special Powers) Act. Indian army gets impunity under this act. It allows soldiers to “fire upon or otherwise use force”, even to the causing of death, against those violating the law.  It also says “no prosecution, suit or legal proceedings shall be instituted, except when there are some previous sanctions of the central government”. The act also provided special powers to enter and search any premises without a warrant. These actions can have serious socio-political repercussions.

AFSPA is imposed in areas affected by internal rebellion, insurgency or militancy. This act provides the armed forces with an enabling environment to carry out their duties without fear of being prosecuted for their actions. But at the same time, it is a general notion that in a democracy, the army must be employed for a milted period and its deployment cannot be prolonged indefinitely. But in reality, this is not the case (e.g like Nagaland continues to be disturbed). Sometimes it is only the excuse and an alibi for poor governance. 

AFSPA - YES OR NO?

Supporters of this Act call it enabling as it is there to protect the soldiers. Its constitutional validity has been upheld by the supreme court of India. It comes into effect only after the government declares a state, or parts of it, as disturbed where normal functioning of government has broken down and the army has to be brought in to restore the normalcy. Therefore, provisions are made through this act for the protection of the armed forces during operations. 

Army’s view is based on its perception of the ground realities especially in Jammu and Kashmir i.e. India is fighting a proxy war. Secondly, cases of hot pursuit could take troops from areas where Act is in force to where it may have been revoked, leading to legal complications as well as allowing terrorists to create safe havens for themselves. Thirdly, after the de-induction of US-led forces in Afghanistan there is a possibility of a rise in terrorist violence in the coming years. 

Also once it is revoked, political compulsions will not allow its re-introduction even if the situation in the state worsens. Case in point Imphal (Manipur) – there was seen a spurt in militant activities since the lifting of disturbed area status. But at the same time, there is a real danger of AFSPA becoming a symbol of oppression if the voices from regions affected by terrorism and insurgency, along with international opinion are not heard and their grievances not addressed. 

An extraordinary situation requires an extraordinary law and therefore existing laws which deal with routine law and order issues will prove inadequate to overcome the challenges. However, as the external threat recedes or when operations are conducted in the hinterland, population approach becomes important because possibility of human rights violations increases.

An analysis of past cases shows that protests against the AFSPA followed custodial deaths and fake encounters ( in Jammu and  Kashmir, Manipur) and not the fierce encounters on the line of control. Therefore, as the nature of threat vary, so must the approach for the conduct of operations. Justice Jeevan Reddy committee has also recommended that the Act be revoked. 

Armed forces (Special Powers Act) 1958

Armed forces (Special Powers Act) 1958 – First time imposed for disturbed areas of Assam and UT of Manipur. Central Government of India passed the North Eastern (Reorganisation) Act in 1971 and created the states of Manipur, Tripura, Meghalaya and UT of Mizoram and Arunachal Pradesh. In 1972 armed forces act was amended. It was amended as Armed forces Special Powers (Amendment) Act, 1972. (Armed Forces Special Powers Act of 1958 lowered the rank of the competent officer thus allowing almost every soldier to use force with impunity.)

Armed forces (Punjab and Chandigarh) Special Powers Act, 1983

Armed forces (Punjab and Chandigarh) Special Powers Act, 1983 – Outbreak of militancy in Punjab in the early 1980s necessitated this. There was a demand for separate Khalistan for Sikhs in 1982. Struggle for hegemony among various Sikh factions as well as simultaneous rebellion against central government worsened the security situation. This act was withdrawn in 1997.

Armed forces (Jammu and Kashmir) Special Powers Act, 1990

Armed forces (Jammu and Kashmir) Special Powers Act, 1990 – An armed separatist movement started in Kashmir in 1989. It had domestic and foreign element. Domestically, the central government’s tendency to impose its will on state without considering the political aspirations of the people alienated them. Externally, Kashmir has been a bone of contention between India and Pakistan. Initially, the insurgency was purely indigenous but soon Pakistan starts supporting insurgents.

However, following the supreme court of India rulings, some safeguards have been introduced by the army. The “Do’s and Don’t” issued by army authorities which army personnel are required to strictly follow:

  • minimum force is used by the armed forces against suspected persons.

  • Arrested persons handed over to the nearest police station within 24 hours

  • army has initiated a number of cases against its personnel accused of violating the basic human rights. 

Cons of AFSPA:

  • It can be held in violation of article 21

  • also overrides CrPC (The Code of Criminal Procedure ). CrPC establishes the procedure for police officers to follow in case arrest, search and seizures, regarding the dispersal of assemblies, the procedure that army and other paramilitary are not trained to follow.

  • e.g. Under IPC (Indian Penal Code), a member of an unlawful assembly is punishable with imprisonment and a fine. The same offence committed under AFSPA is punishable by death. It violates the constitutional right to equality before the law. Different standards of punishment for same act in different parts of the country, violating equality standards set out in the constitution.

  • to file suit against a member of armed forces (under AFSPA) permission must be sought from Ministry of Home Affairs.

There is no denying the fact that the situation is still extraordinary. Unless they find a substitute for AFSPA to address the question, AFSPA will continue to hold the upper hand. Police do not come under AFSPA and confusion shows up every time AFSPA is blamed for police atrocities. The best solution can be political settlement to resolve the core issues that have fuelled social unrests. 

Decisions of calling in the armed forces are backed by assessments, reviews, discussions, consultation with political leaders, opinion-makers, civil services, intelligent agencies, local police and armed forces. It is a complex process. Also, the links of the groups operating in the area with anti-national elements operating elsewhere, and their ability to orchestrate terrorist actions in different parts of the country has also been an important consideration for the decision-makers. But, the other view that prevails is that the army has vested interest in operating without worrying about judicial scrutiny and is obstructing efforts that are being made to roll back the Act.

The validity of this act was challenged in Supreme Court in the case Naga People Movement of Human Rights Vs UoI (1998). Supreme Court ruled that it is not in violation of the provisions of the constitution. 

It is a fact, the act confers extra-ordinary powers which have been allegedly misused by military, police and parliamentary personnel but it is also a fact that despite numerous mass protests, legal challenges the act was neither being reviewed nor repealed. 

Committees should be created at district levels with representatives of army, police, civil administration and public to report, assess and track complaints. Investigations should be time-bound and efforts to be made to keep detailed records of the operations. Moreover, the army’s principle of minimum force must remain a fundamental guideline.

As of now AFSPA is in force in Assam , Nagaland and parts of Arunachal Pradesh and Manipur as well as in Jammu and Kashmir. 

afspa
previous post
Uniform Civil Code In India
next post
India – Pakistan War History Till Now

Recent Posts

  • What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

    5th January 2023
  • Recognizing Gaslighting

    10th December 2022
  • What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

    21st October 2022
  • Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

    18th August 2022
  • What are VPNs, and why are they in the news always?

    29th July 2022

Subscribe Newsletter

Subscribe my Newsletter for new blog posts, tips & new photos. Let's stay updated!

NewsFeed

  • WHO Report on Eliminating Trans Fats Around the World

    7th February 2023
  • Climate change destroying unique kelp forests

    4th February 2023
  • What is short selling?

    2nd February 2023
  • What exactly is China’s ‘Chunyun’? 

    31st January 2023
  • After 50,000 years, a ‘green comet’ will approach the planet

    27th January 2023
  • 2023 UN World Social Report

    20th January 2023
  • Global Risk Report 2023

    16th January 2023
  • What is a recession?

    13th January 2023
  • Tokyo is crowded that the government is paying families to relocate

    10th January 2023
  • Green Hydrogen Explained

    7th January 2023

Article Archives

Editor’s Picks

  • International Organisations List

    7th October 2020

Social Counter

facebook Like
instagram Follow Us

Popular Posts

  • 1

    World Economic Forum (WEF)

    27th January 2021
  • 2

    China Taiwan Conflict

    7th October 2021
  • 3

    European Union

    20th October 2019
  • 4

    Sunni and Shia Differences and ISIS Conflict

    1st October 2019
  • 5

    Armenia-Azerbaijan Conflict

    9th October 2020

Posts Slider

What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

5th January 2023

Recognizing Gaslighting

10th December 2022

What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

21st October 2022

Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

18th August 2022

What are VPNs, and why are they in...

29th July 2022

Few terms coming up in focus to understand...

29th July 2022

U.S. Fed interest rate hike and its impact...

17th June 2022

Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past...

27th May 2022

Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the...

23rd May 2022

The world faces a growing stagflationary storm

5th May 2022

What is and Why De-Dollarisation?

22nd April 2022

International Energy Agency (IEA)

15th April 2022

Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)

12th April 2022

United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC)

10th April 2022

Does Splinternet mean the end of the Internet?

6th April 2022

Quote

"unexamined life is not worth living" - SOCRATES

"law is a reason free from passions"- ARISTOTLE

"he who wishes to be obeyed must know how to command"- MACHIAVELLI

"be kind, for everyone you meet is fighting a hard battle"- PLATO

"prepare for the worst; expect the best; and take what comes"- HANNAH ARENDT

"he who knows only his own side of the case knows little of that"- J S MILL

  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • Youtube
  • Topics
  • NEWSFEED
  • Videos
  • Miscellaneous
  • Contact
  • Privacy Policy

@2022 All Right Reserved

Politics Science News
  • Home
  • Topics
    • Economics Environment Global Reports/Agreements In pictures Intl. Organisations Personalities Politics Science & Tech Theory / Facts World World History All
      Economics

      Few terms coming up in focus to understand…

      29th July 2022

      Economics

      Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the…

      23rd May 2022

      Economics

      The world faces a growing stagflationary storm

      5th May 2022

      Economics

      What is and Why De-Dollarisation?

      22nd April 2022

      Economics

      Explained – The U.S. Federal Reserve to increase…

      8th February 2022

      Economics

      All you need to know about the Natural…

      24th January 2022

      Economics

      The Truth about “Tax the Rich”

      27th December 2021

      Economics

      Venezuela Crisis

      2nd October 2021

      Environment

      World Air Quality Report 

      28th March 2022

      Environment

      Why should we be worried about topsoil erosion?

      21st March 2022

      Environment

      Effects of Climate Change

      30th July 2021

      Environment

      Implications of a Tragic Love Story – Coral…

      4th June 2021

      Global Reports/Agreements

      IPCC Report 2022

      8th March 2022

      Global Reports/Agreements

      The Climate Change Negotiations – UNFCCC and Paris…

      3rd August 2021

      Global Reports/Agreements

      Understanding World Happiness Report

      15th April 2021

      In pictures

      World War 2 Summary (1939 to 1945)

      9th July 2020

      In pictures

      World War I – 1914-1918

      30th June 2020

      Intl. Organisations

      What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

      5th January 2023

      Intl. Organisations

      International Energy Agency (IEA)

      15th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO)

      12th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      United Nations Human Rights Council (UNHRC)

      10th April 2022

      Intl. Organisations

      What is the G20 Summit?

      31st October 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      What is QUAD? | Quadrilateral Security Dialogue

      10th October 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      SCO – What is Shanghai Cooperation Organisation?

      28th September 2021

      Intl. Organisations

      G7 GROUP

      24th September 2021

      Personalities

      Gramsci Prison Notebooks

      18th November 2021

      Personalities

      John Stuart Mill: Theories

      10th September 2021

      Personalities

      Understanding Rousseau, Jean-Jacques

      4th July 2021

      Personalities

      John Locke – Father of Liberalism

      14th June 2021

      Personalities

      Hobbes Leviathan – Political Philosophy of Hobbes

      22nd May 2021

      Personalities

      Chanakya Strategies in administration

      30th March 2021

      Personalities

      Who was Machiavelli? – The Prince Summary and…

      3rd March 2021

      Personalities

      Aristotle – A Greek Philosopher

      25th January 2021

      Politics

      What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

      21st October 2022

      Politics

      Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

      18th August 2022

      Politics

      Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past…

      27th May 2022

      Politics

      Sudan’s Nightmare: The Conflict Explained

      9th January 2022

      Politics

      What’s happening between Ukraine and Russia?

      12th December 2021

      Politics

      China Taiwan Conflict

      7th October 2021

      Politics

      Taliban taking over Afghanistan

      18th August 2021

      Politics

      Armenian Genocide – What Happened?

      24th April 2021

      Science & Tech

      What are VPNs, and why are they in…

      29th July 2022

      Science & Tech

      Does Splinternet mean the end of the Internet?

      6th April 2022

      Science & Tech

      What you must know about the world’s first…

      2nd January 2022

      Science & Tech

      Omicron: Everything you need to know about COVID-19…

      5th December 2021

      Science & Tech

      Dopamine Happy Hormone

      14th August 2021

      Science & Tech

      How to avoid trans fat?

      7th August 2021

      Science & Tech

      Mental Health during the COVID19 pandemic 

      27th June 2021

      Science & Tech

      CRISPR Nobel Prize 2020 – What is it…

      27th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      What is Fascism?

      21st July 2021

      Theory / Facts

      Banality of Evil

      14th July 2021

      Theory / Facts

      Evolution of Western Political Thought

      19th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      What is Game Theory in Politics?

      10th December 2020

      Theory / Facts

      Demarcation of Powers and Responsibilities

      13th September 2019

      Theory / Facts

      Realist vs Idealist

      2nd September 2019

      World

      The Truth about Chernobyl Nuclear Disaster

      28th February 2022

      World

      Djokovic Visa Controversy – More Than What Meets…

      17th January 2022

      World

      Happiest Countries in the World – Top 10

      5th April 2021

      World

      5 Women making history in 2021 – Women…

      21st March 2021

      World

      Five demonstrations that changed history

      5th February 2021

      World

      Myanmar Story

      2nd February 2021

      World

      India and Global Nuclear Order

      31st January 2021

      World

      Nuclear Proliferation

      30th January 2021

      World History

      Israel Palestine Conflict

      11th May 2021

      World History

      What is Cold War? – Cold War Summary

      11th February 2021

      World History

      Russian Revolution

      10th January 2021

      World History

      The Soviet Union Collapse and End of Cold…

      30th December 2020

      World History

      French Revolution – What happened?

      3rd December 2020

      World History

      American Revolution Summary

      28th November 2020

      World History

      South Korea vs North Korea

      12th September 2020

      World History

      World War 2 Summary (1939 to 1945)

      9th July 2020

      Topics

      What is the Wassenaar Arrangement?

      5th January 2023

      Topics

      What is China’s ‘Wolf Warrior’ Diplomacy?

      21st October 2022

      Topics

      Latest on Tunisia and Arab Spring

      18th August 2022

      Topics

      What are VPNs, and why are they in…

      29th July 2022

      Topics

      Few terms coming up in focus to understand…

      29th July 2022

      Topics

      Dispute between Armenia and Azerbaijan – The past…

      27th May 2022

      Topics

      Why are special drawing rights (SDR) in the…

      23rd May 2022

      Topics

      The world faces a growing stagflationary storm

      5th May 2022

  • NewsFeed
  • Miscellaneous
  • Videos
  • Archives